Background While diffuse atherosclerotic disease affecting the posterior circulation has been described extensively, the prevalence, natural history and angiographic characteristics of isolated symptomatic basilar artery stenosis (ISBAS) remain unknown.
Methods We reviewed our prospective institutional database to identify patients with ≥50% symptomatic basilar artery (BA) stenosis without significant atherosclerotic burden in the vertebral or posterior cerebral arteries. Stroke mechanism, collateral circulation, and degree and length of stenosis were analysed. The primary outcome was time from index event to new transient ischaemic attack (TIA), acute ischaemic stroke (AIS) or death. Other outcome variables included modified Rankin Scale (mRS) score on discharge and last follow-up.
Results Of 6369 patients with AIS/TIA, 91 (1.43%) had ISBAS. Seventy-three (80.2%) patients presented with AIS and 18 (19.8%) with TIA. Twenty-nine (31.9%) were women and the median age was 66.8±13.6 years. The mean follow-up time was 2.7 years. The most common stroke mechanism was artery-to-artery thromboembolism (45.2%), followed by perforator occlusion (28.7%) and flow-dependent/hypoperfusion (15.1%). The percentage of stenosis was lower in patients who had favourable outcome compared with those with mRS 3–6 on discharge (78.3±14.3 vs 86.9±14.5, p=0.007). Kaplan-Meier curves showed higher recurrence/death rates in patients with ≥80% stenosis, mid-basilar location and poor collateral circulation. Approximately 13% of patients with ISBAS presented with complete BA occlusion.
Conclusion ISBAS is an uncommon (1.43%) cause of TIA and AIS. Men in their 60s are mostly affected, and artery-to-artery embolism is the most common stroke mechanism. Mid-basilar location, ≥80% stenosis and poor collateral circulation are important factors associated with worse prognosis.
- basilar artery stenosis
- ischaemic stroke
- transient ischemic attack
- intracranial atherosclerotic disease
- stroke mechanism
- collateral circulation
- posterior circulation
This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
- basilar artery stenosis
- ischaemic stroke
- transient ischemic attack
- intracranial atherosclerotic disease
- stroke mechanism
- collateral circulation
- posterior circulation
Atherosclerosis affecting intracranial and extracranial arteries is the most common stroke mechanism in the posterior circulation.1 The New England Medical Center Registry reported that 60% of strokes in the posterior circulation were due to atherosclerosis.2 With 407 patients included from 1988 to 1996, this registry assessed stroke mechanism and the presence of atherosclerosis using imaging modalities that do not have the sensitivity and specificity of the current technologies and protocols.
The advent of new endovascular techniques and devices has broadened treatment options for patients with atherosclerotic disease in the posterior circulation. This has sparked the interest to better characterise the haemodynamics, presence of perforators and stroke mechanisms in the posterior circulation, specifically the basilar artery (BA).3 4 In order to adequately study the potential of new endovascular procedures, it is necessary to better understand the natural history and stroke mechanisms of atherosclerotic lesions in different locations.
Data from the Stenting versus Aggressive Medical Therapy for Intracranial Arterial Stenosis (SAMMPRIS) trial have shown that perforator stroke is the most common complication of angioplasty and stenting of symptomatic BA atherosclerotic disease.5 It is not known whether this mechanism is inherently related to the endovascular procedure or the arterial disease itself. Since atherosclerosis is a systemic disease, patients with atherosclerosis in the posterior circulation tend to have multiple lesions, thus making assumptions of stroke mechanism challenging.
In some patients the primary atherosclerotic lesion is located in the BA. Since all previous studies have included subjects with diffuse atherosclerosis affecting also the vertebral arteries, vertebrobasilar junction and posterior cerebral arteries, the presentation and natural history of isolated symptomatic basilar artery stenosis (ISBAS) have not been fully characterised. This study describes the angiographic features and aetiological mechanisms of a cohort of patients with ISBAS. We focused on the BA given its potential for unfavourable outcomes when treated conservatively with medical therapy or invasively with endovascular procedures.
After obtaining institutional review board approval, we analysed our prospectively acquired database of patients who presented to our institution from 2001 to 2018 with acute ischaemic stroke (AIS) or transient ischaemic attack (TIA) due to BA atherosclerotic disease, as documented by at least ≥50% stenosis of the vessel lumen on CT angiography (CTA), contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance angiography (MRA), time-of-flight (TOF) sequences or digital subtraction angiography (DSA). CTA images were obtained on a 64-slice multidetector CT scan. Contrast-enhanced MRA and TOF images were obtained on a 3T magnetic resonance scan.
The aim of the study was to identify patients with ISBAS. Therefore, patients with significant additional atherosclerotic involvement (≥50% stenosis) of the vertebral arteries (V1–V4 segments) or posterior cerebral arteries were excluded. The BA atherosclerotic plaque had to affect at least ≥50% of the vessel lumen. Patients who presented with AIS due to an acute BA occlusion were included if the underlying aetiology was the presence of an atherosclerotic plaque, seen after successful mechanical thrombectomy and as described elsewhere.6
The angiographic characteristics of the atherosclerotic lesion and imaging data were analysed independently by a neurointerventional surgeon and a vascular neurologist blinded from the clinical outcome. The level of inter-reader agreement was assessed by Cohen κ statistics. Specific characteristics such as length of the lesion, degree of stenosis and location of the plaque were reviewed and recorded. The degree of stenosis (%) was quantified as: [1 − (D stenosis/D normal)]×100, where D stenosis is the diameter of the artery at the site of the most severe stenosis, and D normal is the diameter of the proximal normal artery.7
Lesion location was divided into three anatomical segments for analysis (figure 1): proximal (vertebrobasilar junction to the origin of the anteroinferior cerebellar arteries (AICAs)), mid-BA (AICA to the superior cerebellar arteries (SCAs)) and distal (the distal BA after the SCAs). Location and vascular distribution of the index stroke in patients who presented with AIS were also collected. Demographic characteristics, clinical presentation, stroke risk factors, treatment and outcomes were also analysed.
The stroke mechanism was categorised as either due to a perforator occlusion, flow-dependent/hypoperfusion or artery-to-artery embolism (figure 2) based on clinical and imaging data. This was similar to the criterion used for adjudication of ischaemic stroke mechanisms in the SAMMPRIS trial and described elsewhere.5 8 A perforator occlusion was a brainstem infarction in close proximity to the presence of a plaque in the BA that correlated with vascular territory of the perforator. The criterion for flow-dependent/hypoperfusion mechanism was an infarction and/or TIA localised distal to the BA plaque and triggered or exacerbated by orthostatism or lower blood pressure challenges. Several infarctions distal to the BA plaque without evidence of orthostatism or lower blood pressure worsening were categorised as artery-to-artery thromboembolic mechanism. When more than one potential mechanism could have contributed to the stroke, the stroke mechanism was categorised as uncertain. Patients with possible cardioembolic causes of stroke, such as atrial fibrillation, mechanical valves or presence of an intracardiac thrombus on echography, were excluded from the analysis.
We assessed the degree of collateral circulation to the BA based on the presence of posterior communicating arteries (PCOMs). Whenever possible, we reviewed DSAs to determine PCOMs’ patency. TOF imaging is flow-dependent, and bidirectional flow through collaterals may lead to false signal loss and mischaracterisation of the vessel as being occluded.9 Conversely, contrast-enhanced CTA and MRA depict the vascular contour based on vessel patency. If the DSA was not available, CTA/MRA were preferred over TOF for BA and PCOM characterisation. Our stroke imaging protocol includes a cerebral TOF and a neck contrast-enhanced MRA that cranially extends to the circle of Willis.
A score was assigned according to the presence and diameter of PCOMs (figure 3): dominant=2 points; hypoplastic=1 point; and absent=0 point. The total score ranged from 0 (ie, no PCOMs) to 4 (ie, two dominant PCOMs), with 0–1 points considered ‘low/poor’ collateral flow and 2–4 points ‘high/good’ collateral flow.
All recurrent cerebral ischaemic events (TIA/AIS/death) after the index event were considered as the primary outcome. Secondary outcomes included functional outcome measured by the modified Rankin Scale (mRS) score on discharge and last follow-up. For analysis purposes the mRS was dichotomised as favourable outcome (mRS 0–2) and unfavourable outcome (mRS 3–6). This study followed the Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology guidelines.10
Discrete variables are reported as the number and percentage of patients presenting with the condition for each of the secondary outcomes. t-Test and Kruskal-Wallis test were used for continuous normal and non-normally distributed variables, respectively. χ2 and Fisher’s exact tests were used for categorical variables. Sensitivity analysis eliminating patients presenting with acute 100% occlusion was performed in certain instances to better delineate the effect of the associations. Kaplan-Meier curves and log-rank tests were used to assess the prognostic value of collateral circulation scores, and the degree, length and location of (ISBAS) over time until recurrent TIA/AIS or death. Events that occurred beyond 72 months of follow-up were censored for the analysis. P value <0.05 was set as statistically significant. Statistical analysis and graphic display of data were performed using GraphPad V.7.03 (GraphPad Software), SAS V.9.3 software and R V3.3.3.
A total of 6369 patients were screened, and 91 patients (1.43%) met the inclusion criteria for ISBAS (figure 4). Twenty-nine (31.9%) were women and the median age was 66.8±13.6 years (table 1). Fifty-seven (62.6%) patients underwent endovascular treatment, and only 4 (4.3%) patients received intravenous thrombolysis. Sixty-eight (74.7%) patients were assessed using DSA, 10 (11%) with CTA, 9 (14.3%) with MRA and 4 (4.4%) with TOF. The mean follow-up time was 2.7 years. Four patients died during hospitalisation.
Female gender was associated with unfavourable outcome on discharge (OR 2.63, 95% CI 1.03 to 6.67, p=0.04). Hyperlipidaemia was associated with good mRS score on discharge (OR 3.3, 95% CI 1.3 to 8.1, p=0.008). However, this association was not significant for mRS score at last follow-up (p=0.27) or multivariable analysis, suggesting it was an incidental statistical artefact with a confounding effect. Smoking status, history of diabetes, hypertension, coronary artery disease and previous TIA/AIS were not associated with unfavourable outcomes.
Seventy-three (80.2%) patients presented with AIS and 18 (19.8%) with TIA. As expected, AIS presentation was significantly associated with poor outcome on discharge (OR 16, p<0.001). This finding was significant even in patients without complete occlusion (OR 11, p=0.006). Similarly, high score on the National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale (NIHSS) at presentation was associated with mRS 3–6 at discharge (mean NIHSS score 9.0 (4.0–15.0), p<0.001) and at follow-up (mean NIHSS score 7.0 (4.0–10.0), p<0.001).
Most patients received medical treatment with either a single antiplatelet (12.1%, 11/91) or dual antiplatelets (74.7%, 68/91). There was a significant association between antiplatelet therapy and good mRS score on discharge (p<0.001). Inter-reader agreement was excellent for both location of BA stenosis (κ=0.87, 95% CI 0.7 to 1.0) and PCOM collateral score (κ=0.92, 95% CI 0.87 to 0.95). Better neurological outcomes (mRS 0–2) at discharge and last follow-up were recorded along the 17 years of data included in the study; however, this time-dependent association was not statistically significant (p>0.05) (figure 5).
In patients who presented with AIS, the stroke mechanism was artery-to-artery thromboembolism in 33 cases (45.2%), perforator occlusion in 21 cases (28.7%) and flow-dependent in 11 cases (15.1%). In eight patients (11%) the stroke mechanism was uncertain. The relationship between stroke mechanism and poor collateral circulation (score 0–1) was for flow-dependent stroke=10/11 (90.9%), for artery-to-artery thromboembolism=24/33 (72.7%) and for perforator=13/21 (61.9%), without statistical significance (p=0.14). The stroke mechanism did not correlate with functional outcome.
Degree of stenosis
The mean percentage of stenosis was 81.8±14.7. The percentage of stenosis was significantly lower in patients who had favourable outcomes at discharge (78.3±14.3) compared with those with poor outcome (86.9±14.5, p=0.007). When excluding patients with 100% occlusion (six mid-basilar and six proximal/distal), p value turned more significant between lower degree of stenosis and favourable outcome on discharge (p=0.002) (table 2).
Most TIAs/AIS/deaths occurred during the first 6 months in Kaplan-Meier curves using ≥80% stenosis as cut-off value (figure 6A). When assessing for collateral circulation, 43 of 56 (76.8%) patients with <80% stenosis had no PCOMs or only one hypoplastic PCOM (score=0–1). Conversely, 8 of 21 (38.1%) patients with ≥80% stenosis had at least two hypoplastic or one dominant PCOMs (score=2–4) (p=0.15; figure 6B). Of note, 12 (13.2%) patients with BA occlusion were included in the study and 4 had mRS 5–6 on discharge.
Location of the atherosclerotic lesion
Fifty (54.9%) patients had mid-basilar stenosis, 35 (38.5%) had proximal stenosis and only 6 (6.6%) had distal stenosis. Kaplan-Meier curves showed higher recurrence rates in patients with mid-basilar stenosis compared with proximal or distal stenosis. This difference was not significant in the 72-month censored curves (p=0.193), but statistical association increased in the 6-month censored plot (p=0.08) (figure 6C). There was no significant association between location of the stenosis and mRS score on discharge (p=0.77) or mRS score on last follow-up (p=0.33). Interestingly, patients who smoked were more likely to have mid-basilar stenosis (p=0.026).
Length of stenosis
The average length of stenosis was 4.7±3.0 mm. Kaplan-Meier curves for length of stenosis plotted using a cut-off value of 4 mm showed no association with more events over time. Patients with poor outcome on discharge had a median length of stenosis of 5.2±3.8 mm compared with 4.3±2.4 mm in patients with good outcome (p=0.19). No significant association was found for mRS score on last follow-up (p=0.52).
Previous studies only included the BA in the context of diffuse vertebrobasilar atherosclerotic burden, which makes the assessment of isolated BA disease difficult. Atherosclerotic lesions of the BA are a treatment challenge due to their eloquent location and the large number of perforators that originate at this level. In this study we characterised the clinical presentation, angiographic characteristics and functional outcomes of ISBAS.
ISBAS is uncommon. In this 17-year cohort of patients, ISBAS represented 1.4% of the total number of TIAs and AIS. Most of these patients were men (68%), and the average age at presentation was 66 years old. Studies by Lee et al and Kim et al 6 of patients (15 and 19 patients, respectively) who presented with acute BA occlusion and underlying atherosclerosis also reported an average age of 67.1 and 66.8 years old, with male predominance (80% and 68%, respectively). A case series of Bai et al 11 reported a mean age of 61 years old in a series of 91 patients with severe BA symptomatic stenosis; 72% were men.
As suggested by Gutierrez et al,12 vessel wall stress induced by blood flow leads to intimal thickening. These compensatory responses may regress over time.13 However, in a minority of individuals between 20 and 40 years old, arteries may undergo pathological intimal thickening. In the case of BA atherosclerosis, this process may peak and become symptomatic in the sixth decade of life. Moreover, our study showed an association between smoking and the development of isolated symptomatic mid-BA stenosis, suggesting that external risk factors may expedite BA atherogenesis. Also, a high-resolution MRI (HRMRI) study of BA stenosis (>50%) showed that smoking was an independent risk factor of posterior circulation strokes (OR 4.4, 95% CI 2.2 to 15.9, p=0.024).14
It is unclear why some patients develop isolated BA plaque without more prominent vertebrobasilar involvement. The BA has inherent characteristics that differ from other arteries of the circle of Willis. Postmortem pathological studies have demonstrated that BA plaques have a concentric distribution instead of eccentric as in the anterior circulation,15 higher incidence of intraplaque haemorrhage,16 higher proportion of internal elastic lamina and less elastin as compared with the anterior circulation.17 In our cohort, mid-BA segment stenosis was the most common location correlated with higher recurrence rates in the first 6 months after the index event. This may be related to the increased number of perforators originating from the mid-BA segment.18 Kim et al 6 also reported that the most common location of acute BA occlusion in a cohort of patients with underlying atherosclerotic lesions was the mid-BA segment (38.5%), compared with proximal (30.8%) and distal locations (15.4%).Bai et al 11 reported similar results: mid-BA=63%, proximal=30.8% and distal locations=15.4%. Endovascular angioplasty and stenting of the mid-BA segment are more challenging due to the risk of disrupting the atheromatous plaque and occluding perforators with a snow-ploughing effect.19 20 A post-hoc analysis of all the complications of SAMMPRIS by Derdeyn et al demonstrated that 8 of the 10 procedural-related AIS involving the BA were primarily related to local perforator infarction, and 7 of 8 of the pontine strokes were evident immediately on awakening from anaesthesia.5 Bai et al reported a series of 91 patients who underwent endovascular BA stenting for severe symptomatic stenosis (63% mid-BA) with a 14.3% rate of stroke and haemorrhage in the 30-day perioperative period.11
Localisation of a distal BA occlusion is most likely embolic in nature rather than to an underlying BA atherosclerotic lesion. Distal atherosclerotic lesions of the BA are rare and should not be the first option at the time of determining the stroke mechanism of the top of the BA occlusions. Mid-BA atherosclerotic lesions more likely cause in situ thrombosis and complete BA occlusion. This difference is important at the time of endovascular intervention, as recanalisation of acute BA occlusion in this setting may entail angioplasty and even acute stenting.6 The higher incidence of mid-BA plaques as compared with proximal and distal plaques may be partially explained by haemodynamic flow turbulence at the mid-BA, where the flow bends because of the mid-BA angle.21 The blood flow recovers its laminar flow at the distal BA, which may partially explain the low incidence of distal BA stenosis (6.6%). Length of stenosis ≥4 mm did not significantly impact the event recurrence (HR=1.14, 95% CI 0.55 to 2.37, p=0.72).
Natural history and outcome
The percentage of stenosis was significantly lower in patients who had favourable mRS score at discharge (78.3±14.3) as compared with those with poor outcome (86.9±14.5, p=0.007). Collateral PCOM circulation to the top of the BA may also influence outcomes. van der Hoeven et al 22 showed that better collateral circulation is associated with better outcomes in BA occlusion.
Artery-to-artery thromboembolism was the most common mechanism of infarction in ISBAS. Previous studies describe in situ atherosclerotic thrombosis associated with poorer outcomes,4 while other studies used the classic Trial of Org 10172 in Acute Stroke Treatment (TOAST) classification criteria and did not find any significant relationship.23–26 Of note, these studies did not exclude patients with vertebrobasilar disease, and artery-to-artery thromboembolic events from vertebral artery atheromatous plaque played an important role in stroke mechanism. In our study, in situ thrombosis was probably the stroke mechanism in the 12 patients (13.2%) who presented with 100% occlusion. Outcome of this population with complete BA occlusion and underlying atherosclerotic plaque is known to be poor.
To date, there is no consensus regarding treatment of patients with ISBAS who fail the maximal medical therapy used in the SAMMPRIS trial. Perhaps, there is no universal solution, and individualised approaches should be tailored to the specific vascular anatomy and pathology. A recent study showed that visualisation of BA branches is difficult with current imaging modalities, and HRMRI may be used to identify eccentric atherosclerotic plaques and the ostia of major BA side branches to guide endovascular therapy.27 We hypothesise that HRMRI of BA stenosis will help in selecting patients for clinical trials of endovascular treatment by better characterisation of plaque morphology, stroke mechanism and presence of perforators. Our study shows that ISBAS lesions are more common in the mid-BA segment and portend a poor prognosis with approximately 13% of patients presenting with complete occlusion.
ISBAS is an uncommon disease in this cohort since most patients have diffuse atherosclerotic disease throughout the vertebrobasilar system. Almost 90% of patients were Caucasians, thus limiting the generalisability of our results to other Asian and non-Caucasian populations with high prevalence of intracranial atherosclerosis. This cohort of patients was screened from a 17-year long database; in this time frame intervention techniques and medical practice have changed significantly. The SAMMPRIS trial was published in 2011, and before that medical treatment of intracranial atherosclerosis was not standardised. However, this study is not aimed to determine the best treatment of ISBAS, but to reflect the natural history of the disease.
Plaque characterisation measurements were performed with different imaging modalities (DSA, CTA, MRA and TOF), which decreases accuracy. However, the percentage of stenosis should not be affected by this heterogeneity. Furthermore, conventional MRA/TOF can underestimate the degree of stenosis due to the presence of an atherosclerotic plaque. Cross-sectional HRMRI has shown that 15% of patients who initially had irregular or normal BA on MRA indeed had ≥40% stenosis.28 Therefore, the incidence of ISBAS may be underestimated with current imaging modalities. Finally, stroke mechanisms cannot be determined with complete certainty.
ISBAS represents about 1.5% of AIS and TIAs. It is more common in men, mostly in the mid-60s. The mid-BA segment is most commonly affected, and the most common stroke mechanism is artery-to-artery thromboembolism. Patients with mid-BA stenosis, ≥80% stenosis and poor collateral circulation have worse functional outcomes than those with proximal or distal locations, lesser degree of stenosis and at least one dominant PCOM. Approximately 13% of these patients present with a complete BA occlusion.
Contributors EAS, AS and EL: conception and design of the study. EAS, AS, JAR, BD: acquisition and analysis of data. EAS, JAR, EL: drafting of the manuscript/preparation of figures. SO-G, DMH, CD, HA: substantial scientific revision.
Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
Competing interests None declared.
Patient consent for publication Not required.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Data availability statement Data are available upon reasonable request.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.