Table 1

Summary of model structure and main data sources used in the cost-effectiveness studies of rtPA for acute ischaemic stroke

Study/Year/
Country
PerspectiveInterventionModelling methodEconomic dataClinical data
Data collection/ AnalysesPrevious literatureData collection/ AnalysesPrevious literature
Te Ao et al 36/2015/New ZealandHealth funder perspectiveIV rtPA use within 4.5 hours after onsetSimulation model (TreeAge, Excel)NoYesYes
ARCOS III
Yes
Yan et al 33/2015/ChinaChinese public health system perspectiveIV rtPA use within 6 hours after onsetDecision treeYesNoYesNo
Boudreau et al 24/2014/USAUS payers’ perspectiveIV rtPA use within 3 hours after onsetDecision tree, and Markov model (Excel)Yes (rtPA cost)
Analy$ource
YesNoYes
Pan et al 34/2014/ChinaHealthcare payers’ perspectiveIV rtPA use within 4.5 hours after onsetDecision tree and Markov modelYes
CNSR, CHSY
TIMS-China
NoYes
TIMS-China
Yes
Boudreau et al 25/2013/USAPayers’ perspectiveIV rtPA use within 3–4.5 hours after onsetDecision tree, and Markov model (Excel)Yes
Medicare reimbursement
YesNoYes
Kazley et al 26/2013/USA (SC)Societal perspectiveIV rtPA use within 3 hours after onsetMarkov modelYes
Hospital billing, HCUP
NoNoYes
Tan Tanny et al 31/2013/AustraliaSocietal and healthcare perspectiveIV rtPA use within 4.5 hours after onsetDecision analytic model (Excel), and Monte Carlo simulationYes
Royal Melbourne Hospital
YesYes
Royal Melbourne Hospital
Yes
Tung et al 27/2011/USASocietal perspectiveIV rtPA use within 3–4.5 hours after onsetA decision-analytic model (TreeAge)NoYesNoYes
Johnston28/2010/USANAIV rtPA use within 3 hours after onsetNANoYesNoYes
Ehlers et al 37/2007/DenmarkNAIV rtPA use within 3 hours with 24 hours in house neurology coverage andMRIDecision tree with Markov model (TreeAge)Yes
Aarhus Hospital and Hvidovre Hospital data
YesYes
Aarhus Stroke Register,
Death Register
Yes
Mar et al 38/2005/SpainSocietal perspectiveIV rtPA use within 3 hours after onsetMonte Carlo simulation (4000, no modelling)Yes
Sakontzen questionnaire and social service experts
YesYes
Survey from hospitals in the province of Gipuzkoa
Yes
Moodie et al 32/2004/AustraliaHealthcare perspectiveIV rtPA use within 3 hours after onsetMORUCOSYes
NEMESIS
NoYes
NEMESIS
No
Sandercock et al 29/2004/UKHealthcare and personal social services perspectiveIV rtPA use within 6 hours after onsetDecision analysis model (TreeAge)Yes
Western General Hospital, Edinburgh
YesNoYes
Chambers et al 30/2002/UKHealthcare and social care perspectiveIV rtPA use within 3 hours after onsetStroke Outcome Model (TreeAge, Excel)Yes
Clinicians’ panels
YesNoYes
Sinclair et al 35/2001/CanadaHealthcare system perspectiveIV rtPA use within 3 hours after onsetDecision analytic model (TreeAge), and Markov modelYes
Vancouver Hospital and Health Sciences Centre
YesNoYes
Fagan et al 9/1998/USAHealthcare system perspectiveIV rtPA use within 3 hours after onsetMarkov modelYes (rtPA cost)
Seven Detroit area hospitals
YesNoYes
  • ARCOS III, Auckland Regional Community Stroke Study.

  • CNSR, China National Stroke Registry.

  • CHSY, China Health Statistics Yearbook.

  • HCUP, Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project.

  • IV rtPA, intravenous recombinant tissue plasminogen activator; NA, not applicable.

  • MORUCOS, Model of Resource Utilization, Costs, and Outcomes for Stroke.

  • NEMESIS, North East Melbourne Stroke Incidence Study.

  • TIMS-China study, Thrombolysis Implementation and Monitor of acute ischaemic Stroke in China study.